GenCon is a cornerstone event in the tabletop and trading card gaming industry. Every year, it brings together thousands of fans, creators, and retailers from around the world. Beyond the games and excitement, GenCon 2023 gained widespread media attention due to an unprecedented card heist that left a mark on the entire community.
During GenCon 2023, two individuals managed to steal a pallet packed with high-value trading cards. These stolen items included sought-after sets from Magic: The Gathering, Flesh and Blood, and Disney Lorcana. The heist, valued at over $190,000, was executed with audacity, as the thieves used a pallet jack to abscond with the merchandise from Pastimes Comics & Games, one of the event’s most prominent vendors. The brazen nature of the crime sparked intense discussions about event security and trust at conventions.
In May 2025, one of the accused, Thomas Dunbar, accepted a plea deal that allowed him to avoid jail time. Instead, he was sentenced to probation, ordered to pay restitution, and required to perform community service. He must also write an apology letter to GenCon and its fans, plus serve a two-year ban from entering the Indiana Convention Center, the venue of the theft. Details on the case and the legal proceedings can be read in this Star City Games report.
This outcome highlights the complexities of handling large-scale thefts in the gaming industry. The recovery of the stolen cards was a relief for many, but the trust between vendors and organizers faced new scrutiny. For an in-depth overview of court proceedings and the broader business context, you can refer to the analysis from ICv2: First of Gen Con Heist Crew Sentenced.
Despite the incident, GenCon remains the premier gathering for hobby gamers and enthusiasts. Organizers immediately ramped up security measures and reassured exhibitors of their commitment to protecting attendees and vendors. The resilience of both the event and its community proved stronger than this challenge, underscoring GenCon’s status as the heart of tabletop culture.
For those seeking ongoing updates on crime and high-profile heist cases related to GenCon, including interviews and exclusive coverage, check out the Indianapolis Star’s comprehensive archive.
The 2023 card heist serves as a cautionary tale for conventions everywhere. It emphasizes the need for vigilance and proactive security strategies. At the same time, it demonstrates the importance of a tight-knit community that values both fun and fairness. As GenCon continues to grow, its organizers, exhibitors, and attendees carry forward important lessons from these events, ensuring a safer and more enjoyable experience for all.
While no images from the event are available for inclusion, the story of the GenCon 2023 heist will remain a significant chapter in the event’s long and storied history.